Official Report: Scottish Parliament inquiry into the environmental impacts of salmon farming (6 Feb)

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #1

 

The official transcript of the Scottish Parliament's inquiry into the environmental impacts of salmon farming on 6 February is now online here (and as a PDF online here)

 

 

Watch a video report online here – featuring oral evidence from David Sandison of the Scottish Salmon Producers Organisation, Sam Collin of Scottish Wildlife Trust, John Aitchison of Friends of the Sound of Jura, Anne Anderson from the Scottish Environment Protection Agency, Rob Raynard & James McKie from Marine Scotland and Mark Harvey from Highland Council. 

 

SP TV 6 Feb 2018 panel David Sam John

SP TV 6 Feb 2018 panel 2 with SEPA

 

The official transcript includes:

 

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #2

 

SP TV 6 Feb 2018 John Aitchison map of DEPOMOD inadequate

 

 

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #3

 

SP TV 6 Feb 2018 convenor questioning Sustainable report from SSPO in Nov 2017

 

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #4

SP TV 6 Feb 2018 david Sandison angry face

 

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #5

SP TV 6 Feb 2018 Mark Ruskell pointing figure asking mort & disease question

 

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #6

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #7

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #8

 

SP TV 6 Feb 2018 claudia on sea lice

 

 

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #9

SP TV 6 Feb 2018 david Sandison whopper hands #2

 

 

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #10

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #11

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #12

 

The official transcript continues:

 

SP TV 6 Feb 2018 John Scott on chemical impacts

 

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #13

 

SP TV 6 Feb 2018 Sam #4 hands about funnel for poo in Tasmania

 

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #14

 

Cartoon lobster with gas mask smaller res

 

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #16

 

 

Sunday Herald 19 March 2017 1

Read more via "Slicegate: Anatomy & Chronology of an Environmental Lobotomy"

 

 

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #17

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #18 ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #19

SP TV 6 Feb 2018 david Sandison whopper hands high

 

 

The official transcript continues:

 

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #20

 

SP TV 6 Feb 2018 Alex Rowley on disease and millions loss on 20% loss

  ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #21

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #22

 

In fact, a Scottish Parliamentary Reply in January 2018 shows how the mortality rate is going up and now stands at 26.7% with 12.85 million missing farmed salmon!

 

PQ Mort rate 26

Read more via Press Release: "Scottish Salmon's Mort Mountain Leaps Over 10 Million – FOI reveals 2.3 million dead salmon at Marine Harvest farms in 2017"

 

 

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #23

Photo gallery #1
 

 

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #24

 

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #25

 

RSPCA 20 million

 

 

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #26

SP TV 6 Feb 2018 david Sandison #2

 

 

The official transcript continues:

 

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #27
 

SP TV 6 Feb 2018 Sam #3 hands

 

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #28

 

SP TV 6 Feb 2018 Stewart Stevenson

 

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #29

 

SP TV 6 Feb 2018 John Aitchison on diseases in cleaner fish Norwegians very worried

 

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #30

A9 spill March 2017

Read more via Photo Gallery: Dead Salmon from Scotland's Disease-Ridden Salmon Farms

 

 

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #31

 

 

Billy Bowie bin

 

 

The official transcript continues:

 

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #32

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #33

 

SP TV 6 Feb 2018 Kate Forbes on ADDs and seals

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #34

 

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #35

 

#9 Dead seal

 

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #36

ECS paper abstract 1 May 2017

Read more via Sunday Herald: "Health of whales, dolphins and porpoises put at risk by underwater alarms" ; "Cetaceans Sound Alarm On Salmon Farms – new research sparks EC complaint & call to ban Acoustic Deterrent Devices" and "Large-scale underwater noise pollution from Acoustic Deterrent Devices (ADDs) on the west coast of Scotland"

 

 

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #37

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #38

 

Logo with seals whales porpoises

Read more via "Freedom for Fish" and "RSPCA/Freedom Food & Seal Killing FOI Backgrounder (May 2017)"

 

 

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #39

 

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #40

Sunday Times 31 Dec 2017 #1

Read more via Sunday Times: "‘Clean fish’ bring danger of disease to salmon farms" and "Risk assessment of fish health associated with the use of cleaner fish in aquaculture

 

 

The official transcript continues:

 

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #41

 

And here's the last exchange of the morning panel before the panel changed:

 

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #42

 

 

SP TV 6 Feb 2018 suspended

 

 

 

After the break a new panel featuring the Scottish Environment Protection Agency, Marine Scotland and Highland Council resumed:

 

SP TV 6 Feb 2018 panel 2 with SEPA

 

The official transcript continues:

 

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #43
 

SP TV 6 Feb 2018 Mark Harvey

 

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #44

SP TV 6 Feb 2018 Anne anderson SEPA hand on chin

 

 

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #45

 

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #46

 

The official transcript continues:

 

SP TV 6 Feb 2018 Kate Forbes asking mort question to 2nd panel

 

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #47

 

SP TV 6 Feb 2018 Rob Raynard volume of morts

 

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #48

Photo from Sunday Herald Oct 2017

 

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #49

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #50

 

Daily Mail 27 Jan 2018 #1 newspaper version double pager

Read more via:

Data on Mortalities & Diseases at Scottish Salmon Farms

Press Release: "Diseased Salmon Slip Net & Spill on Road – Failure to police the transport of dead fish prompts EC complaint"

Sunday Times: "Scots councils ‘failing to enforce EC laws on leaky salmon trucks’"

Daily Mail: "Thousands of fish thrown in a truck – and troubling new questions for salmon farms"

 

 

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #51

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #52

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #53
 

SP TV 6 Feb 2018 Rob Raynard re more vets since 2002

 

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #54

SP TV 6 Feb 2018 Mark Ruskell pointing figure asking mort & disease question

 

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #55

 

BBC One Show photo still 11 December 2017 #1

Watch the BBC's 'The One Show' (11 December 2017) online here (read more via "BBC's 'Dead Salmon Run' Opens Can of Worms" )

 

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #56

 

SP TV 6 Feb 2018 Alex Rowley on BBC lorries leaking

 

 

The official transcript continues:

 

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #57

 

SP TV 6 Feb 2018 Anne anderson SEPA on Emamectin

 

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #58

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #59
 

SP TV 6 Feb 2018 Anne anderson SEPA

 

 

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #60

SP TV 6 Feb 2018 claudia on sea lice
 

 

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #61

 

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #62

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #63

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #64

 

 

The official transcript continues:

 

SP TV 6 Feb 2018 Mark Harvey Highland Council on ADDs due to new Harbour Porpoise legislation

 

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #65 ADD Mark Harvey SNH

 

The official transcript continues:

 

SP TV 6 Feb 2018 Mark Ruskell on seals and US MMPA

ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #66
ECCLR Minutes 6 Feb 2018 #67
 

 

Here's a Tweet following the meeting:

 

Tweet SP Green Party #1

 

A press release issued by the Scottish Green Party (6 February) included:

 

Tweet Ruskell seals MMPA #1

Tweet Ruskell seals MMPA #2

Tweet Ruskell seals MMPA #3

 

 

 

You can download and share video clips from the meeting online here

SP TV 6 Feb 2018 video clips

 

 

Read more via:

 

Scottish Parliamentary inquiry calls for more evidence

Victory for Freedom of Information

Media Update: Scottish Salmon Pledges to Publish Data on Diseases & Lice Infestations

Video: Scottish Parliament inquiry into the environmental impacts of salmon farming

The National: "Scotland's fish farmers to release salmon mortality figures"

Tweet storm at the Scottish Parliament's salmon farming inquiry

'Militant' MSPs Grill Scottish Salmon

Update: Scottish Parliament inquiry into the environmental impacts of salmon farming

The Scottish Salmon Polluters Organisation (SSPO)

Loch Duart – The (Really Not Very) Sustainable Salmon Company

Daily Mail: "Salmon crisis as 2.3m are dumped in nine months"

The National: "Environmental groups urge Scottish fish farms to scale back"

Press Release: "Scottish Salmon's Mort Mountain Leaps Over 10 Million – FOI reveals 2.3 million dead salmon at Marine Harvest farms in 2017"

SSPO "sets the record straight"

Transcript of Scottish Parliament inquiry into the environmental impacts of salmon farming

GAAIA's written submission to the Scottish Parliament inquiry

Review of the Environmental Impacts of Scottish Salmon Farming – call for written evidence (deadline of 8 February)

Daily Mail: "Thousands of fish thrown in a truck – and troubling new questions for salmon farms"

The Scotsman: "Fish farms increase could lead to more seals being shot"

Press Release: "Scottish Salmon Farming 101 – Scottish Parliament inquiry opens 'in early 2018'"

Scottish Salmon Farming 101

Media Backgrounder: Inquiry into Salmon Farming by the Scottish Parliament

"Parliamentary Question: to ask the Scottish Government how many farmed salmon have died in each year since 2012"

"First Minister questioned on leaking wastes from morts – call for a moratorium from Greens"

"Campaigners say 'no more salmon farms' after disease on Lewis kills 125,000 fish"

Scroll to Top