Caught on Camera – Mowi’s Reckless Breaches of Health & Safety in Loch Alsh

Drone footage from Ardintoul 2 Nov 2019 Photo #15 boat hitting kayak

 

HSE Tweet

 

 

Scottish Salmon Watch has filed a formal complaint against Norwegian salmon giant Mowi (formerly called Marine Harvest) with the Health & Safety Executive and the Maritime & Coastguard Agency following incidents in Loch Alsh on 2 November 2019. 

 

"Drone footage clearly shows that Mowi endangered the health and safety of the general public during an inspection of a salmon farm in Loch Alsh 'Special Area of Conservation'," wrote Don Staniford, Director of Scottish Salmon Watch.  "Mowi staff deliberately rammed a kayak, drove at high speed past a small dingy, unclipped a kayak tied safely to the farm, kicked a paddle into the water and scraped a work boot down my Achilles tendon.  Mowi's behaviour on 2 November at Ardintoul was both reckless and dangerous.  Since Scottish Salmon Watch plans further unannounced site inspections and sampling near salmon farms it is a hoped that a protocol can be put in place urgently to properly police surveillance of this unhealthy and unsafe industry."

 

Here's photo stills grabbed from drone video footage taken ca. 8am on 2 November 2019 at Mowi's Ardintoul salmon farm in Loch Alsh (drone footage has been shared with the Health & Safety Executive and the Maritime & Coastguard Agency):

 

Drone footage from Ardintoul 2 Nov 2019 Photo #13 ballast water onto kayak

 

Drone footage from Ardintoul 2 Nov 2019 Photo #1 overview

 

 

Here's the Mowi work boat recklessly speeding past a tiny dinghy safely navigating and filming in public waters:

 

Drone footage from Ardintoul 2 Nov 2019 Photo #2 work boat speeding past dinghy

Drone footage from Ardintoul 2 Nov 2019 Photo #3 work boat speeding past dinghy

Drone footage from Ardintoul 2 Nov 2019 Photo #4 work boat speeding past dinghy

 

 

Here's Mowi deliberately ramming into my safely tied kayak (luckily it was not badly battered and I was able to kayak back to shore):

 

Drone footage from Ardintoul 2 Nov 2019 Photo #9 boat hitting kayak

Drone footage from Ardintoul 2 Nov 2019 Photo #10 boat hitting kayak

Drone footage from Ardintoul 2 Nov 2019 Photo #11 boat hitting kayak

 

Drone footage from Ardintoul 2 Nov 2019 Photo #12 boat hitting kayak

 

Drone footage from Ardintoul 2 Nov 2019 Photo #14 boat hitting kayak

 

Drone footage from Ardintoul 2 Nov 2019 Photo #15 boat hitting kayak

 

 

When the Mowi work boat leaves the cage the engines cause unnecessary stress to the farmed salmon (unlike a kayak which operates quietly and without a motor):

 

Drone footage from Ardintoul 2 Nov 2019 Photo #16 boat motors stressing fish

 

 

Here's a Mowi worker scraping his work boot down my Achilles heel (not once but twice) as they surround and intimidate me (audio recordings of the interactions will hopefully be made available):

 

Drone footage from Ardintoul 2 Nov 2019 Photo #20 scraping Achilles

 

Drone footage from Ardintoul 2 Nov 2019 Photo #22 scraping Achilles

 

 

The same Mowi worker (he also called me a "cunt", "beady eyed" and mouthed "fuck you") is seen here untying my kayak which was safely clipped onto the cage and then throwing the safety rope into the water:

 

Drone footage from Ardintoul 2 Nov 2019 Photo #18 untying kayak

 

Drone footage from Ardintoul 2 Nov 2019 Photo #19 untying kayak

 

 

The Mowi worker is then filmed kicking my paddle into the water with the unclipped kayak now dangerous drifting away from the farm (at the same time another Mowi worker is ironically asking me to leave the site – even though my paddle and kayak are in danger of floating off into Loch Alsh):

 

Drone footage from Ardintoul 2 Nov 2019 Photo #23 kicking paddle

 

Drone footage from Ardintoul 2 Nov 2019 Photo #24 kicking paddle

 

 

When the Mowi worker fails to kick the paddle into the loch he moves to try for a second attempt (as a Mowi work boat emblazoned with the words "Safety First" docks alongside the cage).  He appears to stop and looks up at the drone filming his every move:

 

Drone footage from Ardintoul 2 Nov 2019 Photo #25 safety first

 

Drone footage from Ardintoul 2 Nov 2019 Photo #26 paddle kicked for 2nd time

 

Drone footage from Ardintoul 2 Nov 2019 Photo #27 looking up at drone

 

 

The kayak floats along the cage as the Mowi worker seems to be beckoning the work boat to smash it against the farm:

 

Drone footage from Ardintoul 2 Nov 2019 Photo #28 kayak floating

 

 

Smile – you're on camera!

 

Drone footage from Ardintoul 2 Nov 2019 Photo #29 smile for the drone

 

 

As Mowi staff walk away a worker succeeds in kicking the paddle into the water (leaving me up shitty salmon creek without a paddle): 

 

Drone footage from Ardintoul 2 Nov 2019 Photo #30 kicking paddle successfully

 

Drone footage from Ardintoul 2 Nov 2019 Photo #31

 

Drone footage from Ardintoul 2 Nov 2019 Photo #32

 

Drone footage from Ardintoul 2 Nov 2019 Photo #33

Drone footage from Ardintoul 2 Nov 2019 Photo #34

 

 

Perversely, the Scottish Salmon Producers Organisation (of which Mowi is the leading member) Tweeted shortly after Mowi's health and safety violations in Loch Alsh.

 

SSPO Tweet re safety

 

 

Scottish Salmon Watch continued to film safely and bio-securely at Mowi's salmon farm and waited in vain for Police Scotland to arrive (a Mowi worker told me when he first approached: "I've phoned my mate from the police and they're on their way").

 

Ardintoul Photo #9 Don

 

 

 

Later that morning after we had returned to the shore, a Mowi worker ensured that Mowi's bins full of disease-ridden salmon were tightly tied shut to stop people seeing the horrors inside: 

 

 

Ardintoul Photo #16 morts tied

 

 

However, before the workers had tied the mort bins shut here's photos of the rotting corpses and freshly diseased mortalities littering Mowi's land-base at Ardintoul:

 

Ardintoul Photo #24 soup

 

Ardintoul Photo #25

 

Ardintoul Photo #20

 

Ardintoul Photo #19

 

 

Here's video reports from Mowi's salmon farm at Ardintoul on 2 November 2019:

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

In September 2019, Scottish Salmon Watch wrote to the Maritime & Coastguard Agency expressing serious concerns with respect to the reckless behaviour of Mowi (over two months later we have still not received a reply). 

 

Letter to Maritime & Coastguard Agency 12 September 2019 #1

 

Letter to Maritime & Coastguard Agency 12 September 2019 #2

 

Letter to Maritime & Coastguard Agency 12 September 2019 #3

 

Letter to Maritime & Coastguard Agency 12 September 2019 #4

 

Letter to Maritime & Coastguard Agency 12 September 2019 #5

 

 

In August and July 2019, Scottish Salmon Watch wrote to the Health & Safety Executive, Police Scotland, the Cabinet Secretary for Justice and other agencies proposing guidelines for filming with respect to salmon farms (thus far there has been no reply).

 

HSE blog #1

 

HSE blog #2

HSE blog #3

 

HSE blog #4

 

In August 2019, Mowi's salmon farm at Ardgour in Loch Linnhe was the subject of a complaint to the Health & Safety Executive following filming in July 2019 by Scottish Salmon Watch.

 

HSE Animal Concern Aug 2019 Letter #4

HSE Animal Concern Aug 2019 Letter #5

 

 

 

Read more via:

 

 

Addendum:

 

On 31 March 2020, the Maritime & Coastguard Agency finally replied to Scottish Salmon Watch's complaint dated 15 November 2019:

 

From: Alyson McGinnigle <Alyson.McGinnigle@mcga.gov.uk>
Date: Tue, Mar 31, 2020 at 3:24 PM
Subject: Complaint Response
To: Don Staniford <salmonfarmingkills@gmail.com>

Dear Mr Staniford

Please find attached our response letter to your recent complaint.

Thank you for your cooperation and please do not hesitate to contact me if you have any further questions relating to the response

Kind regards

Alyson

 

MCA Complaint Reponse Letter 6 April 2020 #1a signature

 

 

MCA Complaint Reponse Letter 6 April 2020 #1

MCA Complaint Reponse Letter 6 April 2020 #2

 

 

MCA Complaint Reponse Letter 6 April 2020 #3 email asking for complaints procedures

 

 

In February 2020, Scottish Salmon Watch filed a FOI request with the Maritime & Coastguard Agency:

 

 
From: Don Staniford <salmonfarmingkills@gmail.com>
Date: Fri, Feb 28, 2020 at 4:01 AM
Subject: FOI request re. salmon farms since 1 Jan 2019
To: <informationassurance@mcga.gov.uk>, <infoline@mcga.gov.uk>
 
 
FOI Request from Scottish Salmon Watch (28 February 2020):
 
Please provide information relation to salmon farms since 1 January 2019.
 
Please include correspondence with salmon farming companies, government agencies and other information.
 
Please include complaints from the public and internal emails (including with other government departments and other parties) in relation to salmon farms.
 
This would include any correspondence, emails and discussions in relation to various letters sent by Scottish Salmon Watch:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
And it would include any discussions of various blogs relating to salmon farms including:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Please consider this a formal request for information under the relevant FOI and Environmental Information Regulations.
 
 
Please provide the information electronically.
 
Please provide a receipt for this FOI request.
 
Thanks,
 
Don Staniford
 
Director of Scottish Salmon Watch
 
 
 
 
 

From: navigation safety <navigationsafety@mcga.gov.uk>
Date: Thu, Mar 26, 2020 at 11:17 AM
Subject: RE: FOI request re. salmon farms since 1 Jan 2019
To: salmonfarmingkills@gmail.com <salmonfarmingkills@gmail.com>
Cc: InformationAssurance <InformationAssurance@mcga.gov.uk>, Directorate of Maritime Safety and Standards Business Unit <dmss.bu@mcga.gov.uk>

Dear Mr Staniford,

Thank you for your recent request for information under the Freedom of Information Act. I have attached our response letter and some email correspondence pertaining to your request.

Please note, due to recent changes to MCA working arrangement following the COVID-19 outbreak, we have been unable to redact a hard copy of the email correspondence. Instead, all names, job titles, and phone numbers in the attached electronic copy have been replaced with ‘X’.

We have received notification that the ICO offices are closed, meaning they are unable to collect their post. Therefore if you are not satisfied with the decisions and you wish to apply to the ICO, please use the following link which will connect to their website:  http://ow.ly/oWiW50yU9Xb

Best regards,

Nick Salter

 

MCA FOI reply 26 March 2020 signature Nick Salter

 

MCA FOI reply 26 March 2020 picture of attachments

 

Download MCA FOI reply 26 March 2020 #1 emails

Download MCA FOI reply 26 March 2020 #2 covering letter FOI 3444

 

 
 

Scroll to Top